English Grammar in Use · Raymond Murphy · 4th Edition

UNIT 95 – Relative clauses 4: extra information clauses (1)

Self-study theory · Varied practice · Repeated testing
Attempts: 0 Best score: – Saved wrong answers: 0 53 scored questions + 3 self-written questions

1.1 · Objectives & essentials

Yes two types relative clause. Type 1 (defining) said WHAT person/thing being talked about; Without it, the sentence will be ambiguous. Type 2 (extra information / non-defining) only more information about a person/thing that we already knew who/what is; Leave it out and the sentence still makes sense.

Type 1: The woman who lives next door is a doctor. → "which woman?" — the person who lives next door.
Type 2: My sister Lan, who lives in Da Lat, is a doctor. → known as Lan; clause is just additional information.

1.2 · Core formulas

Type 1 (definite): noun + who/which/that ... (NO commas) the hotel (that) you recommended Type 2 (complement): clear noun, who/which/whose/where ..., (WITH commas) the Park Hotel, which a friend recommended,
Type 1 – definiteType 2 – additional information
Functionclearly indicate which person/thingMore information about the person/thing is clear
Comma❌ no✅ yes (both sides of the clause)
Use that?✅ okay❌ NO
Omit pronouns (when used as object)?✅ okay❌ NO
whomrarely usedCan be used as an object
whose / where✅✅

1.3 · A. When is an additional clause?

  • The noun in front is own name: Hanoi, which is the capital of Vietnam, ...
  • Yes possessive adjective + unique noun: my father, my new job, our office (only one).
  • It's an object unique: the sun, the moon.
  • Listener already know it is who/what from the context.

1.4 · B. Don't use that, don't leave out who/which

  • John, who (not that) speaks five languages, works as a guide.
  • I met Chris, who I hadn't seen for ages. — must keep who (not say I met Chris, I hadn't seen for ages).
  • In formal speech: I met Chris, whom I hadn't seen for ages.

1.5 · C. whose and where are used for both types

Type 1: We met some people whose car had broken down. Type 2: Lisa, whose car had broken down, was in a bad mood. Type 2: Kate has just been to Sweden, where her daughter lives.

1.6 · Commas change meaning

SentenceMeaning
My brother who lives in Hue is a teacher.I have many brothers; People living in Hue are teachers.
My brother, who lives in Hue, is a teacher.I have an older brother; By the way, he lives in Hue.

1.7 · Common errors

❌ Wrong✅ Correct
My mother, that is a nurse, works nights.My mother, who is a nurse, works nights.
Hanoi which is very crowded is my home town.Hanoi, which is very crowded, is my home town.
I visited Ha Long Bay, I loved very much.I visited Ha Long Bay, which I loved very much.
The man, who called you, left a message.The man who called you left a message.

Book cross-references: Units 92–94 (clause type 1) · Unit 96 (clause type 2 part 2: of whom, which = whole clause).