English Grammar in Use · Raymond Murphy · 4th Edition

UNIT 93 – Relative clauses 2: clauses with and without who/that/which

Self-study theory · Varied practice · Repeated testing
Attempts: 0 Best score: – Saved wrong answers: 0 56 scored questions + 3 self-written questions

1.1 · Objectives & essentials

Unit 92 introduced the relative clause (the woman who lives next door). This unit answers the important question: When is who/that/which REQUIRED, and when is it OMITTED? The key lies in the relative pronoun playing the role subject nice neologism in relative clause.

The man who lives upstairs is a pilot. → who is subject of "lives" → cannot be omitted.
The man (who) I met yesterday is a pilot. → who is neologism of "met" (subject is I) → can be removed.

1.2 · Core formulas

Subject: noun + who/that/which + VERB ... (must keep) the people who work here the bus that goes to the airport Object: noun + (who/that/which) + SUBJECT + verb ... (can be omitted) the people (who) I work with the book (that) you lent me
The role of who/that/whichThe sign is right behind itCan I quit?Example
Subjectone verb❌ Nothe girl who won the prize
objectone new subject (I, you, Tom...)✅ Yesthe girl (who) Tom loves

⚠️ Quick identification tips: look from right behind the gap. If so verb → must have who/that/which. If so pronoun/noun as subject → can be abandoned.

1.3 · A. who/that/which as subject — cannot be omitted

  • The woman who lives next door is a doctor. — don't say The woman lives next door is a doctor.
  • Where's the cake that was on the table? — don't say Where's the cake was on the table?
  • If omitted, the sentence is yes two main verbs stand next to each other and become grammatically incorrect.

1.4 · B. who/that/which as object — can be omitted

  • The film (that) we watched last night was boring.
  • Have you found the wallet (that) you lost?
  • Is there anything (that) I can do?
  • Relative clause has been replaced object, should not repeat it/them/him: the wallet you lost (not the wallet you lost it).

1.5 · C. Prepositions come at the end of relative clauses

Tom is talking to a woman. → the woman (who/that) Tom is talking to I slept in a bed. → the bed (that/which) I slept in You can rely on somebody. → somebody (who) you can rely on

In ordinary speech and writing, the preposition (to, in, for, with, about, on...) stay last clause, in its correct place in the original sentence. Do not add extra pronouns: the books you were looking for (not ... looking for them). More formal way with whom/which comes after the preposition learned in Unit 94.

1.6 · D. that or what?

that (or leave blank)what
Stand behinda noun / everything / anything / all / nothing / the best...a verb/preposition, no front noun
Meaning"which" — connects to the preceding noun= the thing(s) that — "that, that"
ExampleEverything (that) she said was true.I didn't hear what she said.

📏 After everything, anything, all, nothing, something, the only, the best, the worst → use that or leave blank, NO Use what.

1.7 · Compare with structures that are easy to mistake & common errors

❌ Wrong✅ Correct
The people work in that office are friendly.The people who work in that office are friendly.
The phone I bought it last week is broken.The phone I bought last week is broken.
Everything what he told me was a lie.Everything (that) he told me was a lie.
The hotel we stayed was lovely.The hotel we stayed at was lovely.
Tell me that you need.Tell me what you need.

Book cross-references: Unit 92 (relative clauses 1) · Units 94–96 (whose/whom/where, additional information clause) · Unit 97 (-ing/-ed clauses shortened).