English Grammar in Use · Raymond Murphy · 4th Edition

UNIT 57 – Verb + -ing or to ... 2 (try/need/help)

Self-study theory · Varied practice · Repeated testing
Attempts: 0 Best score: – Saved wrong answers: 0 56 scored questions + 3 self-written questions

1.1 · Objectives & essentials

This unit learns 3 verbs meaning changes depending followed by to + V nice V-ing: try, need and help (same idiom can't help). The key: look intention of the speaker — are try or are try? Me need to do, good objects need to be done?

I tried to open the window, but it was stuck.
→ try but can't do it.
The room was hot, so I tried opening the window.
→ can do, that is a try See if it cools down.

1.2 · Core formulas

try to + V = try to do (may not be able to do it) try + V-ing = try to do (as a test / solution) need to + V = need to do (subject is the person doing it) S + need(s) + V-ing = need to be done (= need to be + V3) help (to) + V = help (with or without to is correct) can't help + V-ing = can't help it, can't help it
Verb+ to V+ V-ing
trytry: I tried to lift the box (but it was too heavy).try: Try restarting your phone.
needperson to do: I need to wash my car.Items to be made: My car needs washing.
helpShe helped me (to) carry the bags.— (only in can't help -ing)
can't help—I can't help laughing.

1.3 · A. Try to ... and try -ing

  • try to do = make an effort, do your best. Often accompanied by the idea "difficult/unlikely to do": I tried to stay awake, but I fell asleep. · Please try to be on time.
  • try still has meaning try (to see the results): Try this soup — it's delicious. · We tried every shop in town.
  • If try (= try) goes with a verb → uses try -ing: — The printer isn't working. — Try turning it off and on again.
I tried to move the sofa, but it was too heavy. (try - can't do it) I tried moving the sofa to the window, but it looked worse. (try – do it, but don't like it)

1.4 · B. Need to ... and need -ing

  • I need to do = it is necessary for me: I need to drink more water. · You don't need to come tomorrow.
  • Something needs doing = thing/thing needed okay do (passive meaning): My shoes need cleaning. (= need to be cleaned) · This plan needs thinking about carefully.

⚠️ need -ing carries meaning passive even without "be": The grass needs cutting = The grass needs to be cut. Don't say The grass needs to cut.

1.5 · C. Help and can't help

  • help to do or help do — both are correct: Everyone helped (to) tidy the classroom. · Can you help me (to) fix this?
  • I can't help doing = I can't stop myself from doing it: He's so annoying, but I can't help liking him. · She couldn't help crying at the end of the film.
  • I can't help it = I couldn't help it (it): Sorry I keep yawning — I can't help it.

1.6 · Recognition signals

Signs in sentencesChooseExample
"…but I couldn't / it was too…" (failure)try toI tried to reach the top shelf, but I was too short.
Solution suggestions: Try…!, Have you tried…?, You could try…try -ingHave you tried using a different charger?
The subject is an object (car, hair, windows...)need(s) -ingThe windows need cleaning.
The subject is do-it-yourselferneed toI need to clean the windows.
can't / couldn't help-ingI couldn't help smiling.

1.7 · Comparison with easily confused structures

Unit 57 (try / need / help)Unit 56 (remember / stop / regret…)
Main ideato = try/people need; -ing = try/thing to be doneto = later; -ing = previous work
ExampleTry calling her. / The door needs painting.Remember to call her. / I remember calling her.
❌ Wrong✅ Correct
My phone needs to charge.My phone needs charging. / needs to be charged.
I can't help to laugh.I can't help laughing.
Have you tried to restart it? (suggested solution)Have you tried restarting it?
I tried lifting it, but it was too heavy.I tried to lift it, but it was too heavy.
She helped me carrying the bags.She helped me (to) carry the bags.

Book cross-references: Unit 53 (verb + -ing) · Units 54–55 (verb + to…) · Unit 56 (remember/regret/go on…) · Unit 58 (like / would like…).