English Grammar in Use · Raymond Murphy · 4th Edition

UNIT 28 – Must and can't

Self-study theory · Varied practice · Repeated testing
Attempts: 0 Best score: – Saved wrong answers: 0 53 scored questions + 3 self-written questions

1.1 · Objectives & essentials

This unit not talk about "what to do" (see Units 31–32), but about logical reasoning: rely on evidence to draw conclusions definitely right (must) or definitely not possible (can't). With the past, use must have done / can't have done.

My house is very near the motorway. — It must be very noisy.
No one directly said it was noisy, but from the evidence (near the highway) → speaker suy ra almost certainly.

1.2 · Core formulas

PRESENT must / can't + be (tired, at work…) must / can't + be + V-ing (joking, waiting…) must / can't + V (know, have, get…) PAST must / can't + have + been (asleep…) must / can't + have + been + V-ing must / can't + have + V3 (gone, got…) couldn't have = can't have She couldn't have got my message.
Definitely TRUEDefinitely NO
CurrentlyYou must be tired.You can't be hungry already.
PastThey must have gone out.She can't have got my message.

⚠️ The negation of must (inference) is can't, NOT mustn't. mustn't = forbidden (Unit 32).

1.3 · A. Must = I believe this is definitely true

  • You've been travelling all day. You must be tired.
  • 'Joe is a hard worker.' 'Joe? You must be joking!'
  • Louise must get very bored in her job. She does the same thing every day.
  • I'm sure she gave me her address. I must have it somewhere.

1.4 · B. Can't = I believe this is impossible

  • You've just had lunch. You can't be hungry already.
  • They haven't lived here long. They can't know many people.

1.5 C. Must have done / can't have done (past)

  • Nobody answered the door. They must have gone out.
  • 'I've lost a glove.' 'You must have dropped it somewhere.'
  • Sarah hasn't replied. She can't have got my message.
  • Tom walked into a wall. He can't have been looking where he was going.

1.6 · Recognition signals

SignalChoose
Supportive evidence (always full, all day, so quickly…)must
Evidence to the contrary (always empty, just eaten, only arrived yesterday…)can't
Conclusion about what happened (last night, when I got back…)must have / can't have + V3
Conclusion of ongoing actionmust be + V-ing

1.7 · Comparison & common errors

❌ Wrong✅ Correct
It's always empty. It mustn't be good.It can't be good.
They must went out.They must have gone out.
He must to be at home.He must be at home.
She can't has got my message.She can't have got my message.
You must be joke.You must be joking.
I didn't hear the phone. I must be asleep.I must have been asleep.

Book cross-references: Unit 26 (can't = not capable) · Units 31–32 (must = must, mustn't = forbidden) · Unit 29 (may/might – less certain) · Appendix 4 (modal verbs).