This unit not talk about "what to do" (see Units 31–32), but about logical reasoning: rely on evidence to draw conclusions definitely right (must) or definitely not possible (can't). With the past, use must have done / can't have done.
| Definitely TRUE | Definitely NO | |
|---|---|---|
| Currently | You must be tired. | You can't be hungry already. |
| Past | They must have gone out. | She can't have got my message. |
⚠️ The negation of must (inference) is can't, NOT mustn't. mustn't = forbidden (Unit 32).
| Signal | Choose |
|---|---|
| Supportive evidence (always full, all day, so quickly…) | must |
| Evidence to the contrary (always empty, just eaten, only arrived yesterday…) | can't |
| Conclusion about what happened (last night, when I got back…) | must have / can't have + V3 |
| Conclusion of ongoing action | must be + V-ing |
| ❌ Wrong | ✅ Correct |
|---|---|
| It's always empty. It mustn't be good. | It can't be good. |
| They must went out. | They must have gone out. |
| He must to be at home. | He must be at home. |
| She can't has got my message. | She can't have got my message. |
| You must be joke. | You must be joking. |
| I didn't hear the phone. I must be asleep. | I must have been asleep. |
Book cross-references: Unit 26 (can't = not capable) · Units 31–32 (must = must, mustn't = forbidden) · Unit 29 (may/might – less certain) · Appendix 4 (modal verbs).
| ❌ What learners often say | ✅ Correct | 🔎 Why |
|---|---|---|
| He mustn't be at home. (meaning: probably not home) | He can't be at home. | negation inference = can't |
| She must is tired. | She must be tired. | after must → V infinitive |
| They must forgot. | They must have forgotten. | past → have + V3 |
| You must be tire. | You must be tired. | tired adjective |
| He can't have saw it. | He can't have seen it. | V3 of see is seen |
| Someone must steal my bike. | Someone must have stolen it. | it happened |
| He must follow us. (following) | He must be following us. | going on → be V-ing |
| Maybe he must be sick. | He must be sick. / He might be sick. | must is certain; maybe → might |
🔁 Spaced review: Do the exercises again after 3 days, 7 days and 14 days. Related: Unit 27 (could have), Unit 29 (may/might), Units 31–32 (must = must).