English Grammar in Use · Raymond Murphy · 4th Edition

UNIT 12 – For and since, When ... ? and How long ... ?

Self-study theory · Varied practice · Repeated testing
Attempts: 0 Best score: – Saved wrong answers: 0 59 scored questions + 3 self-written questions

1.1 · Objectives & essentials

This unit helps you speak How long has something been going on? as of now. Two keywords: for (go with length period) and since (go with starting point). Along with that is how to distinguish questions When ...? (ask when → past simple) and How long ...? (asking how long it is now → present perfect).

I've been waiting for two hours. = I've been waiting since 8 o'clock.
Same thing: "for" measure how long, "since" indicates When did it start?.

1.2 · Core formulas

for + PERIOD of time for two hours / for six months / for ages since + starting point since 8 o'clock / since Monday / since 2019 since + past clause since I left school / since we arrived How long + have/has + S + (been) ...? → How long have you known her? When + did + S + V? → When did you meet her? It's / It's been + about TG + since + past simple It's two years since I last saw Joe.
for (length)since (starting point)
two hours, 20 minutes, five days8 o'clock, Monday, 12 May
a long time, six months, 50 yearsApril, 2001, Christmas
a week, ages, yearslunchtime, we arrived, I got up

⚠️ Test tip: ask questions "how long?" → for. Ask questions "Since when?" → since. since six months is WRONG because "six months" is a length, not a milestone.

1.3 · A. For and since with present perfect

  • Sally has been working here for six months. = ... since April. (from April until now)
  • I haven't seen Tom for three days. = ... since Monday.
  • Since + clause: the verb after since is usually in past simple: He has been looking for a job since he left school.

1.4 · B. Remove "for", "all", and "in"

  • The affirmative sentence is possible remove for: They've been married (for) ten years.
  • Negative sentence tense keep for: They haven't had a holiday for ten years.
  • No Use for + all: I've lived here all my life (don't say for all my life).
  • Negative sentences can be used in instead of: They haven't had a holiday in ten years.

1.5 · C. When ...? and How long...?

QuestionWellReply
When did it start raining?past simple (a moment in time)It started an hour ago / at 1 o'clock.
How long has it been raining?present perfect (continuous)It's been raining for an hour / since 1 o'clock.
When did they first meet?past simpleA long time ago / When they were at school.
How long have they known each other?present perfectFor a long time / Since they were at school.

📌 ago goes with past simple (When...?), for/since goes with present perfect (How long...?).

1.6 · D. It's (been) ... since ...

It's two years since I last saw Joe. = I haven't seen Joe for two years. It's been ages since we went to the cinema. = We haven't been to the cinema for ages. How long is it since ...? / How long has it been since ...?

After since In this sample use past simple (I last saw / we went). The sentence has a negative meaning ("it's been a long time since...") even without "not".

1.7 · Recognition signals

See...UseExample
number + time unit (two days, a month, ages)forfor three weeks
hour, day, day, month, year, eventsincesince Friday / since 2020
clause "S + V past"sincesince she moved here
ago, in 2015, yesterdayWhen + past simpleShe arrived two days ago.

1.8 · Comparison with easily confused structures

for / since (Unit 12)ago (Unit 5)
Meaningextends from the past up to nowtime ago how long
Wellpresent perfectpast simple
ExampleShe's lived here for a year.She moved here a year ago.
❌ Wrong✅ Correct
I've worked here since three years.I've worked here for three years.
I work here for three years.I've worked here for three years.
I've lived here for all my life.I've lived here all my life.
How long ago have you known her?How long have you known her?
When have you started learning English?When did you start learning English?
It's two years since I have seen him.It's two years since I saw him.

Book cross-references: Unit 11 (How long have you (been)...?) · Units 7–8 (present perfect) · Unit 5 (past simple) · Unit 13–14 (present perfect vs past).